Dr. Steffen Schwartz-Höfler

Independent Sustainability Expert & Executive

Big5Sustainability

Sustainability | ESG | Reporting | Governance

Back to homepage

Big5 of Sustainability

A proposal for a different perspective on regulatory overload

A safari with animals is easier to remember than a string of abbreviations. Animals instead of acronyms: become a safari guide or a jungle pathfinder, not an explainer of abbreviations.

Tall grass, a blazing sun, thorny bushes everywhere, and sounds all around us. We wait tensely, wondering what might be hiding behind the next bush. We are in the savannah, searching for the Big5 of sustainability governance and regulation. The term Big Five originally comes from the vocabulary of big-game hunting. It refers to the five large and dangerous animals that big-game hunters set out to kill. Luckily, most people are after a photograph rather than a hunting trophy.

The Big5 represent regulations which Corporation can only fulfill as a whole group. They are top-down regulation. If the parent company falls under the regulations, the entire group needs to follow. Thus, the whole Corporation is either compliant or not. The savannah where you can spot megafauna like the Big5 is very different from the jungle which grows bottom into a very dense forest with little light and countless forms of life. The sustainability regulation jungle consists of all regulation in all jurisdictions which relate to sustainability and have single entities, products or shipments as subjects. Corporation may fulfill these regulations for some entities while not fulfilling them for other entities. There is nothing like a fulfillment for the Corporation as whole.

Top-down vs. bottom-up requirements – savannah and jungle
Top-down vs. bottom-up requirements – savannah and jungle

Top-Down: The Big5 of the sustainability savannah

Let us venture into the safari. Many animals roam our sustainability savannah. Some have only recently been introduced into the reserve, other are already well-known. The safari guides and rangers (aka sustainability managers) can already show the guests (aka company management) plenty of animals.

The largest of the Big Five can be spotted from a long way off. Something large and grey is approaching the rangers. It is an elephant - more precisely, a CSRD elephant. CSRD stands for the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive. Like an elephant, it changes entire ecosystems. Sustainability reporting is being raised to the same level as financial reporting. Step by step, almost every company operating in Europe will be affected. Especially as the CSRD, like a real elephant, does not come alone. A whole herd of ESRS, guidance, practical resources and interpretations accompany it. ESRS stands for the European Sustainability Reporting Standards. They alone are an impressive herd of elephants. In the savannah everything is related to the elephants making them a keystone species. The Voluntary Standards (VS) is the group of younger elephants. They do not have the same power as the adult family members but are still elephants – well protected. Perhaps another elephant or two will emerge from the bushes. Some elephants make mock charges at the guides and guests; others feed peacefully. This is not only depending on the elephants but especially on how the guides and guests behave in the wild. Meanwhile some omnibuses changed the composition of the herd a “little”. The guides are busy dealing with the elephants as guests are very interested in seeing the elephants. At the same time elephants are dangerous animals. So the guides have great respect for these mighty animals. The first photographs and reports of these majestic creatures in the sustainability savannah came in 2025 from the 2024 safari season. A bigger herd can be admired in the 2027 season with photos expected in early 2028.

Without a doubt, the CSRD elephant is the largest animal on the Big Five safari.
Without a doubt, the CSRD elephant is the largest animal on the Big Five safari.

Guides have already seen the buffalo for a longer time but they are still not really sure about their numbers. Some guests and especially the reserve management are enthusiastic about buffalos. But most people do not really care. For them it is just a tick box on their list. Buffalo are social animals as well – they form large herds. The herd of EU Taxonomy buffalo in our sustainability savannah has grown year-by-year through numerous delegated acts, FAQs and more. Buffalo often behave in an unpredictable way. Especially individual older males. As bulk grazers will fight for dark green (business activities) but ultimately eat all kind of green or greenish grass (if the approach survives the discussions with the assurance provider). It is complicated. The reserve provides lots of green to sustain the herd – while trying not to do significant harm elsewhere. Reporting on green business activities under EU taxonomy is similar to the buffet of the buffalo. As the buffalo herd is continuously growing, it is hard to keep track of it and track the green it consumes. The first buffalo photographs were already admired in spring 2023, from the 2022 safari season. Yet most pictures of the herd look different every year, and they have not exactly sparked a wave of enthusiasm.

The EU Taxonomy buffalo herd continues to grow.
The EU Taxonomy buffalo herd continues to grow.

It is hard to find in the savannah. It is a solitary animal and threatened with extinction. It is hunted or better to say poached for their horns – though the horn is the same material as our fingernails. The guests have taken many photographs of the rhino - more precisely, the German Supply Chain Act or German Due Diligence Law rhinoceros (LkSG). Most of the pictures are rather blurry, though, and there is still disagreement about what the rhino really looks like. The rhinoceros has been roaming the savannah as the #LkSG since 2021; official expeditions have been taking place since 2023. The oversight over the population is exercised by a mysterious authority called BAFA. The animal is usually peaceful if left alone. Its eyesight is poor, but it has keen hearing and a fine sense of smell. If it is provoked, you should get to safety quickly. So it is all about due diligence and respecting the rhino (and human rights along the value chain). This is true for guides, guests, lodge staff and everybody related to the reserve. The guides know this well, but have to explain it to the guests again and again, because at first glance the ancient animal seems so calm. The rhinoceros is under constant threat and evolution is about to take place soon.

The solitary rhinoceros of the German Supply Chain Act.
The solitary rhinoceros of the German Supply Chain Act.

Many legendary stories have been told about the king of the animals. For a long time, it looked as though it would not appear on our sustainability safari at all. Some guests not in favour of lions sang the familiar song, "The Lion Sleeps Tonight." But the lion fought his way through and some time it will enter the savannah. It will lead the Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive (CSDDD) pride, together with its lionesses (national implementations) and will try to rule the savannah in an admittedly much smaller territory than desired but trying to protect every antelope, tree and even every insect in it. The pride wants to defend human rights and environmental protection with immense force (potential). They are very modern lions with great ambition, after all. No guest will cross carelessly the territory without a good safari vehicle or without a good guide.

One more shake, and then the CSDDD lion is ready to get moving.
One more shake, and then the CSDDD lion is ready to get moving.

Another inhabitant of the savannah is elusive and rarely seen, yet is always there. It has been strolling around for a long time, and as the safari goes on, its outline becomes easier to make out. Most of the time, you do not notice it. By then, it has already crept up and taken its prey. With its strength, it hauls the prey up into a tree. We are talking about the leopard of the German Corporate Governance Code (DCGK), which in turn is grounded in various statutory provisions. Some of the many DCGK leopard points target sustainability aspects of the work of management and supervisory boards – even though after an update these points are mostly considered indirect rather than explicit. So, they can sometimes be spotted only at second glance. Examples include oversight of strategy integration, reporting, and sustainability-related risks, controls and compliance. Some experienced guides know how to deal with the leopard: they know where to find it and how to take good photographs from a safe distance. But pity the guide who is not sufficiently prepared or experienced with this animal.

Sometimes visible only at second glance: the DCGK leopard.
Sometimes visible only at second glance: the DCGK leopard.

Prepare for the safari

So what should one do with a safari like this, with so many wild animals? Experienced guides recommend the ABCs of a sustainability safari:

Nachhaltigkeits-Ranger auf Big5-Safari

And finally: Stay enthusiastic about the sustainability safari. A club holiday in Mallorca is certainly less complex and demanding than a Big Five safari. But you will never forget the safari for the rest of your life.